Reflective Practice: Gibbs’ and Kolb’s Models Explained

Reflective practice means looking back at something you did, working out why it went the way it did, and deciding what you will do differently next time. For teachers, assessors and IQAs, it turns everyday experience into steady professional growth.

In this guide, we explain the two reflective practice models you are most likely to meet, Kolb’s learning cycle and Gibbs’ reflective cycle. We also show you how to use them in your own portfolio.

What Is Reflective Practice?

reflective practiceHaving an experience is not enough on its own. A tutor can deliver the same lesson for ten years and never improve it. Reflection is the step that turns “that didn’t go well” into a clear plan for next time.

That is why reflective practice runs through almost every teaching and assessing qualification. On the Level 3 Award in Education and Training (AET), you reflect on your micro-teach. On the CAVA, you reflect on how you planned and carried out assessments. As an IQA, you reflect on your sampling and on the feedback you give assessors. It also sits at the heart of keeping your CPD up to date.

Kolb’s Learning Cycle

David Kolb set out his experiential learning cycle in 1984.

His idea is simple: we learn by doing something, thinking about it, making sense of it, and then trying again. The cycle has four stages:

  1. Concrete experience. You do something, such as teaching a session or observing a learner at work.
  2. Reflective observation. You look back on what happened. What went well? What surprised you?
  3. Abstract conceptualisation. You make sense of it. Why did it happen? What theory or good practice explains it?
  4. Active experimentation. You plan what to try next time, then put it into practice. That new attempt becomes your next concrete experience.

Because the cycle loops, learning never really stops. Each round builds on the one before, much like the teaching cycle.

How assessors use it: say a professional discussion with a learner felt rushed. You note that it overran (reflective observation). Next, you realise your questions were too broad (abstract conceptualisation). So you plan tighter, criteria-linked questions for next time (active experimentation).

Gibbs’ Reflective Cycle

Graham Gibbs built on Kolb’s work in 1988, in his guide Learning by Doing. His reflective cycle breaks reflection into six stages. Each one comes with a simple question, so it is a handy structure for written reflections.

Stage Question to ask yourself
1. Description What happened?
2. Feelings What were you thinking and feeling at the time?
3. Evaluation What went well, and what didn’t?
4. Analysis Why did it go that way? What does theory or good practice say?
5. Conclusion What have you learned? What else could you have done?
6. Action plan What will you do differently next time?

The stages most people skip are feelings and analysis. However, these are where the real learning happens. Without them, a reflection is just a description with a to-do list on the end.

A Worked Example: Reflecting on a Micro-Teach

Here is how an AET learner might use Gibbs’ cycle after their micro-teach.

  • Description: I delivered a 15-minute micro-teach on fire safety to four peers. I used a short slideshow, a group quiz and a Q&A at the end.
  • Feelings: I felt nervous at the start and rushed my introduction. I relaxed once the group got involved in the quiz.
  • Evaluation: The quiz worked well, and everyone took part. On the other hand, I ran out of time for the Q&A, so I couldn’t fully check learning.
  • Analysis: I spent too long on the slides because I was reading from them. I also hadn’t set timings for each part of my lesson plan. Good practice says checking learning should be built in throughout, not left to the end.
  • Conclusion: I need to plan my timings and use directed questions during the session, rather than saving them all for the end.
  • Action plan: Next time, I will add timings to my lesson plan, cut my slides to key points only, and ask a question after each section.

Notice how the action plan links straight back to the analysis. That link is what assessors look for.

Other Reflective Practice Models

Kolb and Gibbs are the best known, but you may come across two others in your reading.

Schön: reflection-in-action and reflection-on-action. Donald Schön (1983) split reflection into two types. Reflection-in-action happens in the moment, such as changing your approach mid-session when learners look lost. Reflection-on-action happens afterwards, when you look back on what took place. Good practitioners do both.

Driscoll’s “What?” model. John Driscoll’s model uses three short questions: What? So what? Now what? It is quick to use, so it suits brief notes after an observation or a standardisation meeting.

No single model is “right”. Pick the one that fits the task, and say why you chose it if your assignment asks.

How to Write a Reflective Account for Your Portfolio

A reflective account is a common piece of evidence on the AET, CAVA and IQA qualifications. These tips will help yours hit the mark.

  • Write in the first person. It is your reflection, so “I planned” and “I felt” are exactly right.
  • Choose one model and follow it. Gibbs’ six stages make a clear structure, so each one can become a short paragraph.
  • Be specific. “The session went well” tells your assessor nothing. Instead, say what went well and how you know.
  • Be honest about what didn’t work. Reflection is not about proving you were perfect. Spotting weaknesses shows you are developing.
  • Link to theory and good practice. For example, mention the principles of assessment, or a feedback method such as the praise sandwich.
  • End with clear actions. Make them realistic, and link each one to something you found in your analysis.
  • Keep it current. Write your reflection soon after the event, while the details are fresh.

Reflective Practice and CPD

Reflection doesn’t stop once you are qualified. Assessors and IQAs need to keep their CPD up to date, and reflection is what makes CPD count.

Attending a training day is an activity. Reflecting on it, by asking what you learned and how it will change your practice, turns it into development. That is why a good CPD record includes a short reflection for each activity.

A simple habit helps. After each observation, standardisation meeting or training session, spend five minutes on Driscoll’s three questions. Over a year, those notes become a strong CPD record and a clear picture of how your practice has grown.

Frequently Asked Questions About Reflective Practice

What is the difference between Kolb’s and Gibbs’ models?

Kolb’s cycle has four stages and describes how people learn from experience in general. Gibbs’ cycle has six stages and adds feelings, evaluation and an action plan. As a result, Gibbs is usually easier to use as a structure for written reflection.

Which reflective model should I use for my AET?

Any recognised model is fine, but Gibbs’ reflective cycle is a popular choice. Its six stages give you a ready-made structure for reflecting on your micro-teach.

How long should a reflective account be?

It depends on what your assessor asks for. Focus on covering every stage of your chosen model clearly, rather than hitting a word count.

Is reflective practice only for new teachers?

No. Experienced assessors and IQAs reflect too, both to improve and to keep their CPD up to date.

What is reflection-in-action?

It is Schön’s term for reflecting while something is happening, so you can adjust in the moment. Reflection-on-action happens afterwards.

Develop Your Reflective Practice With Brooks and Kirk

Reflective practice is built into all our courses, from the AET to the CAVA and our IQA qualifications. Because we’re a not-for-profit, our focus is on supporting you properly, and our tutors guide you through every reflective account.

Find out more about the AET qualification here. Explore our CAVA and IQA courses here.

If you have questions about which course is right for you, our team is happy to help. Email us at training@brooksandkirk.ac.uk or call us on 01205 805 155.